What Investors Want Before They Write a Check

s
By soivaStartup
What Investors Want Before They Write a Check
What Investors Want Before They Write a Check

Your Title Here

When you’re trying to turn a promising idea into a viable business, your entire world revolves around hitting the next milestone. Every bit of effort is about raising enough capital not just to reach that next goal, but to have a cushion for the inevitable surprises and a budget to market for the next round of startup funding. It's a game of levels. Even if your grand vision is an IPO or a legacy business, you have to win the level you’re on right now.

One of the most critical levels is the breakeven point. Let’s be real—until you hit breakeven, all your revenue is just burned cash. That’s true whether you’re making a few thousand or a few billion. But the moment you reach that point, the power dynamic shifts. Suddenly, you don’t technically need another dollar of outside money. You’re self-sustaining. Of course, more capital helps you grow faster, but now you’re negotiating from a place of strength, not desperation. This is the moment a side hustle to small business transition becomes a reality.

That said, many of the biggest tech darlings, even those with massive valuations, haven’t broken even. It’s not an absolute requirement for Entrepreneurial Capitalization. As Peter Thiel explained in Zero to One, savvy investors are buying into the future value of your cash flow. If you’re not profitable today, they want to know when you will be and how much that future cash flow is worth. They're essentially buying tomorrow's dollars at a discount today.

Giving Investors What They Really Want

If you're going to succeed in the Investment Process, you need to get inside the minds of investors. It’s less about having the perfect product and more about understanding their psychology. So, what do they really want? It’s easiest to start with what they absolutely want to avoid:

  1. Losing money.
  2. Being made to look foolish.

Everything else is just a way to guard against those two outcomes. Investors have a checklist, whether it's written down or just in their head, designed to prevent these pain points. To get a "yes," you need to tick these boxes:

  • A Solid Plan: A business idea that is well-researched and thought out.
  • Organization: Proof that you have your act together.
  • Integrity: They’re investing in you as much as the idea.
  • Clarity: You have answers to the obvious questions.
  • Self-Awareness: You know what you don't know and have a plan to fill the gaps.
  • Market Potential: The opportunity is big enough to matter.
  • A Path to Repayment: If it’s a loan, how are you paying it back?
  • An Exit Strategy: How will they get their money back (and then some)?
  • Commitment: You’ve poured your heart into this project.
  • Skin in the Game: You have your own resources on the line.
  • Social Proof: You have positive feedback from others.
  • Proof of Demand: You have evidence that people want what you're building.
  • Good Chemistry: They can see themselves working with you.
  • Coachability: You’re open to feedback and guidance.
  • Respect for Their Capital: You’ll treat their money and time with care.
  • A Good Match: The investment aligns with their portfolio and goals.
  • Passion: For your product, your mission, and for working with them.
  • An Opportunity: Something that gets them closer to their own professional goals.

Remember, you're not selling your product to an investor. You’re selling them an investment in your company. This means knowing your investors as well as you know your customers—understanding their fears, goals, and what drives them beyond just ROI. It’s about bragging rights, outdoing their rivals, and backing solutions they genuinely care about.

Stand Out by Outperforming

One of the simplest ways to get an investor’s attention is to crush your competition. Strong performance gives you leverage in negotiations and can even make investors come to you, minimizing the time you spend chasing money.

“Outperforming” can mean different things. Can you beat your rivals on profit margins? Sales growth? Social media engagement? Peter Thiel uses Twitter as an example. While the platform has its challenges, its incredible growth in a declining print news era made people believe in its future potential.

Growth signals that there’s still time for investors to get in at a perceived discount. Find a metric where you have an edge and lean into it. If you’re already stretched thin, how do you find the capacity to pull ahead?

  • Get ruthlessly focused.
  • Find expert help.
  • Get up earlier.
  • Enter startup competitions.
  • Participate in hackathons or coding marathons.
  • Attend industry conferences and networking sessions.
  • Join exclusive, invite-only communities.

Your Story is Your Most Valuable Asset

Most startups have to market themselves hard to get funded. Your regular marketing—branding, website, social media—tells a story to potential investors about your company’s value and DNA. When done right, this marketing can attract angel investors organically.

Storytelling is everything. It’s what separates a technical spec sheet from a movement. Think of TOMS, Patagonia, or Dollar Shave Club—their stories are integral to their brands. Zappos’s story was about culture, Airbnb's was about the sharing economy, and Apple’s is inseparable from Steve Jobs.

The greatest entrepreneurs are, at their core, incredible salespeople. They tell a story so compelling that talented people and smart investors can’t help but join the journey. Many founders get bogged down in technical details that investors can’t relate to. It doesn’t matter how brilliant your innovation is if you can’t connect with people on a human level.

Document your journey. Journaling can help you connect the dots of your own story—what led you here, what drives you, and what makes your solution unique. If you don’t tell your story, investors will make one up in their minds, and it might not be the one you want.

You Don't Have to Do It Alone

If storytelling isn’t your strong suit, get help. The wisest entrepreneurs know what they don’t know and aren’t afraid to lean on experts for business planning, fundraising strategy, or pitch deck design. You’d be surprised who is willing to help if you just ask. In the U.S., there’s a strong pay-it-forward culture.

For tasks that require more than a friendly piece of advice, freelancers can be a startup’s best friend. Platforms like Upwork are full of a freelance business ready to help with everything from copywriting to financial modeling, allowing you to build a world-class team on a shoestring budget.

Ideally, one co-founder should own the fundraising process. Investors generally prefer multi-founder startups anyway; they often worry that a solo founder couldn’t convince anyone else to believe in the idea. Just be careful not to bring on too many founders, as too many cooks can complicate everything. Having a single person in charge of the fundraising initiative streamlines the whole effort.

The Emotional Grind of Fundraising

Let’s be clear: raising capital is an emotional rollercoaster. No matter how much you plan, there will be exhilarating highs and gut-wrenching lows. If you truly care about your vision, you need to prepare for it.

Expect the process to take longer than you think. Be ready for unexpected feedback, frustrating delays, and moments of disappointment. It took the founders of LawPivot, backed by top Silicon Valley lawyers and Google Ventures, plenty of emails and pitch tweaks before they found success.

You have to learn to love rejection. Think of it like a salesperson who knows that every "no" gets them closer to a "yes." When an investor says you're "too early" or "don't have enough traction," what they often mean is "keep me updated." If you execute on your promises and share your progress, you can turn that "no" into a "yes" down the road. Keep them in the loop on your milestones. Building a side hustle business into a funded company requires this kind of resilience.

Remember, raising money is about building relationships first; the capital comes later. As the saying goes, “Ask for money, get advice. Ask for advice, get money twice.” Follow up, add value, and stay on their radar. Nurture those leads, even the ones that seem cold. A thank-you note, a relevant introduction, or a small gift card can leave a lasting impression and keep the door open for the future.

Crafting the Perfect Pitch

Once you have your mindset and story straight, you need the right assets to approach investors for startup funding.

The Problem with Business Plans

Every startup needs a comprehensive business plan. But don’t fall into the trap of thinking a perfectly polished, 100-page document is what will get you funded. Most of the time, the decision to invest is made before anyone even glances at your business plan. It’s a due diligence checkbox, not a conversion tool. A good business plan is important, but your energy is better spent on the tools that actually open doors.

The Pitch Deck: Your Fundraising Currency

The pitch deck is non-negotiable. You’ll need two versions: a detailed one you can email and a visually-driven one for live presentations. The average VC spends just 3 minutes and 44 seconds on a deck, so it needs to be clear, compelling, and easy to act on.

According to Sequoia Capital, your deck should cover these 10 areas:

  1. Company Purpose: What’s your mission?
  2. Problem: What pain point are you solving?
  3. Solution: How do you solve it?
  4. Why Now: What market shifts make your solution timely?
  5. Market Size: How big is the opportunity?
  6. Product: A look at what you’ve built.
  7. Team: Who is behind the vision?
  8. Business Model: How will you make money?
  9. Competition: Who are your rivals and how are you different?
  10. Financials: Your projections and key metrics.

Invest in professional design. A great-looking deck can make a new tech startup look like a seasoned player. Look at examples from companies like Airbnb or LinkedIn to see what a winning deck looks like.

The One-Pager and Elevator Pitch

Your elevator pitch is a 30-second introduction that sparks interest. It’s your key to unlocking the conversation. Practice it until it’s second nature.

A one-pager distills your entire business plan and pitch deck into a single, shareable document. It’s a powerful tool for uniting your team around a single message and making it incredibly easy for investors to understand and share your vision.

Getting Your House in Order: The Due Diligence Package

Once you’ve hooked an investor with your pitch, you need to be ready for the due diligence process. This is where they verify your claims and dig into the nitty-gritty of your business. Being unprepared here is how deals fall apart.

Have a comprehensive due diligence package ready to go in a shared folder (like Google Drive or Dropbox). This shows you’re organized, professional, and understand what’s important to them. While the full list is long, it's about providing clarity on four main areas: the people, the product, the market, and the deal.

Here is a comprehensive (and admittedly intimidating) list of what you might need:

  • Organization: 1.01 Certificate of Incorporation and amendments 1.02 Bylaws 1.03 List of all business names 1.04 List of subsidiaries and affiliates 1.05 List of jurisdictions where you own/lease assets 1.06 List of jurisdictions where you are qualified as a foreign entity 1.07 Board and shareholder meeting minutes 1.08 List of business acquisitions or dispositions 1.09 List of current and former officers/directors
  • Capitalization and Securityholders: 2.01 List of authorized/outstanding securities 2.02 Agreements to issue/register securities 2.03 Voting agreements, rights of first refusal, etc. 2.04 Warrants, options, or other rights to acquire securities 2.05 Stock option plans and grant documents 2.06 Agreements with "finders" for financing 2.07 Private placement memos and related documents 2.08 Copies of stock certificates 2.09 Closing binders from prior equity financings
  • Financials and Taxes: 3.01 Financial statements (past 3 years) 3.02 Schedule of liabilities 4.01 List of jurisdictions where you pay taxes 4.02 Tax returns since incorporation
  • Employees and Labor: 5.01 Employment/consulting agreements, NDAs, etc. 5.02 Labor dispute history 5.03 List of all employees with titles and earnings 6.01 Employee handbooks and policies 6.06 Employee health and welfare plans
  • And Much More... The full checklist can include everything from financial commitments, patents, and insurance policies to litigation history and intellectual property agreements.

You'll also need a clean capitalization (cap) table, which breaks down ownership. Services like eShares can make managing this much easier. And be prepared for background checks. Investors are investing in you, so they’ll want to know you have a clean record. This is the time to clean up your social media and settle any old legal or financial issues.

Funding Sources to Get You Started

So, where does the money actually come from? There are several paths, each with its own pros and cons.

Bootstrapping

This is the art of building your side income business with your own resources. Think sweat equity, ramen noodles, and a Spartan lifestyle. The biggest benefit is that you retain full control and don't answer to investors. It forces you to be frugal, creative, and resilient—qualities that are incredibly valuable. Plenty of billion-dollar companies started with less than $1,000. However, the risk is real. Running out of cash is the fastest way to kill a dream. Bootstrapping works if you can become profitable quickly, but it’s not a long-term strategy for a high-growth startup company.

Credit Cards

If your personal cash runs dry, credit cards can feel like an appealing next step, especially if you want to avoid giving up equity. It's a path many have taken, but it's a dangerous one. Your financial advisor would be horrified. High interest rates can quickly spiral out of control, putting both your good side business and your personal finances in jeopardy. Use this option with extreme caution, if at all.

Related Articles